Which Financial ETF is the best to buy now?

market timing model:

Confirmed Buy – Signal generated on the close of September 4 (click here for more details) (we are on a buy signal from the close of Aug. 16)


today’s watchlist (potential trade entries):

today's watchlist
Having trouble seeing the open positions graphic above? Click here to view it directly on your web browser instead.


open positions:

Below is an overview of all open positions, as well as a report on all positions that were closed only since the previous day’s newsletter. Net P/L figures are based on two separate $50,000 model portfolios (one for ETFs and one for stocks). Changes to open positions since the previous report are listed in pink shaded cells below. Be sure to read the Wagner Daily subscriber guide for important, automatic rules on trade entries and exits.

open position summary
Having trouble seeing the open positions graphic above? Click here to view it directly on your web browser instead.


closed positions:

open position summary
Having trouble seeing the closed positions graphic above? Click here to view it directly on your web browser instead.

ETF position notes:

  • Note that we are selling UWM at market on Monday’s open.

stock position notes:

  • ALLT, ACAT, and PATK triggered on the long side.
  • ACAT’s entry price is an average of the 130 shares existing position and the 70 shares we added on Friday.
  • We raised the stop in LNKD to lock in a 10% move (about a $900 gain).


ETF and broad market commentary:

Initially following through on the previous day’s bullish momentum, stocks rallied in the first hour of last Friday’s session, then drifted sideways to lower throughout the remainder of the day. The Nasdaq Composite ($COMPX) climbed 0.9%, as the S&P 500 ($SPX) and Dow Jones Industrial Average ($DJIA) registered matching gains of 0.4%. Small and mid-caps showed the most relative strength, which is a positive sign for the overall health of the market. The Russell 2000 ($RUT) and S&P MidCap 400 ($MID) indices jumped 1.0% and 1.1% respectively. The main stock market indexes closed near the middle of their intraday trading ranges, but more importantly at fresh multi-year highs.

Bullish market internals again confirmed last Friday’s rally, as increasing volume accompanied the gains in the major indices for the third straight day. Total volume in the NYSE ticked 9% higher, while turnover in the Nasdaq increased 5% above the previous day’s level. In both exchanges, advancing volume beat declining volume by a margin of approximately 3 to 1. After several months of minimal volume throughout the summer (as well as indecisive price action), it is refreshing to see turnover at least returning to 50-day average levels. The return of institutional trading activity helps solidify technical market trends, and last week’s higher volume gains pointed to accumulation of shares among banks, mutual funds, hedge funds, and other big players.

In the September 14 issue of The Wagner Daily, we said, “The market rally continues to pick up steam with more groups participating in the advance. The financial sector has picked up some momentum the past few weeks, with the S&P Select Financial SPDR ETF ($XLF) breaking out from a six-month base on Thursday (September 13).” Today, we will follow-up that analysis by examining in more detail the increasing bullish momentum in the financial sector.

In addition to scanning hundreds of daily ETF chart patterns every night, we also use percentage change charts to compare the performance of numerous industry sectors with the benchmark S&P 500 and/or Nasdaq Composite indices. Rather than showing actual price changes, percentage change charts simply compare relative price performance between two or more indexes, ETFs, or stocks (this concept is thoroughly explained in Advanced Technical Analysis of ETFs, my new ETF trading book that was just published last week). The increasing bullish momentum in the financial ETF we mentioned last Friday can be easily seen on the percentage change chart below, which compares the performance of S&P Select Financial SPDR ($XLF) against the S&P 500 SPDR ($SPY), a popular ETF proxy that tracks the performance of the broad-based S&P 500 Index:

$XLF vs. $SPY chart pattern comparison

On the chart above, notice that XLF started showing slight relative strength to SPY on September 4, but the bullish divergence started became much more clear starting on September 6. Since then, the relative strength of XLF has been increasing, which tells us institutional funds are rotating back into the financial arena. As such, the gain of XLF (7.7%) has nearly doubled the return of SPY (4.3%) over the past 10 days.

Although following the flow of institutional funds from one industry sector to another is a key aspect of our ETF sector trading strategy, it’s important to realize there are typically at least several different ETFs that track the same sector. Therefore, upon identifying relative strength within a particular sector, the next step is to analyze each of the various ETF fund families to see which individual ETF is showing the most relative strength within the sector index. This is necessary because the daily and weekly chart patterns of various ETF families can vary greatly, depending on the underlying stock portfolio that comprises each ETF.

Upon analyzing the charts of quite a few financial ETFs over the weekend, we determined the most relative strength is currently within the Regional Banks sub-sector. Specifically, one of the best ETFs for trading in the financials right now may be S&P Regional Bank SPDR ($KRE). Although the more-diversified XLF closed at a new 52-high last week, it is still trading below resistance of its 2010 and 2011 highs. Conversely, KRE has already broken out above its 2010 and 2011 highs, and is trading at its highest price since late 2008. The relative strength of KRE vs. XLF is shown on the long-term monthly chart patterns of XLF and KRE below:

$XLF monthly chart pattern

$KRE monthly chart pattern

Although our exact entry and exit prices are typically determined from the shorter-term daily chart patterns, the longer-term weekly and monthly chart patterns are important because they show us the “big picture” of the trend. Being on the right side of that trend increases our odds of a successful trade, even if we are only buying the ETF for a short-term, momentum-based swing trade.

Due to its relative strength and lack of significant overhead price resistance (most investors who wanted out of this ETF are already out by now), we now like KRE for potential swing trading buy entry on a pullback. It has much less overhead supply than XLF, and other financial ETFs we compared as well. Along with a few other select ETFs with relative strength, we are now monitoring KRE for buy entry when it retraces to provide a positive reward-risk ratio. Exact entry and exit prices will be listed in the ETF Watchlistsection of the newsletter when/if it meets our criteria for entry.


Our sole open ETF position, ProShares Ultra Russell 2000 ETF ($UWM) came within just 2 cents of our original target price last Friday, before drifting a bit lower into the close. But because UWM came within such close proximity of our price target, and since the ETF is now showing an unrealized gain of 10% since our September 5 buy entry, note that we will be selling UWM at market on Monday’s open to lock in a nice gain.

Given last week’s substantial broad market gains, it would not be surprising for stocks to pull back from their highs, or at least enter a period of sideways consolidation in the coming week. Frankly, we would like to see that happen, as there is currently a lack of new ETF trade setups with low-risk entry points at current levels. On the other hand, we are continuing to build an increasing list of ETFs with relative strength that we are targeting for potential swing trade entry when the market eventually enters into at least a short-term correction by price or time. As always, patience to wait for proper trade entry points with favorable reward-risk ratios is important, so we are not interested in chasing ETFs just for the sake of action. Nevertheless, we will be “locked and loaded” with new ETF trade setups when stocks eventually pull back or start consolidating after their recent gains.


stock commentary:

Our scans did not reveal much in the way of low risk buy setups which is to be expected as we are a bit extended in the short term on most averages. That being said, we know that markets can remain at overboght levels for quite some time. If the market does pull back this week we would expect a short term, 2% to 3% correction off the swing high.

We still like ONXX as a buy setup with the same entry as last Friday, but our stop is now below Friday’s reversal bar low. We are starting with a 12% position and adding to the position on a breakout for a full 20% position. Note the new split stop for DVA. The market is too strong to stay in a stock that is not moving in our direction so we tightened up the stop to limit losses and free up capital.

If you are a new subscriber, please e-mail [email protected] with any questions regarding our trading strategy, money management, or how to make the most out of this report.


relative strength combo watchlist:

Our Relative Strength Combo Watchlist makes it easy for subscribers to import data into their own scanning software, such as Tradestation, Interactive Brokers, and TC2000. This list is comprised of the strongest stocks (technically and fundamentally) in the market over the past six to 12 months. The scan is updated every Sunday, and this week’s RS Combo Watchlist can be downloaded by logging in to the Members Area of our web site.